In today’s global economy, transparency in supply chains is becoming increasingly vital. However, many businesses are less forthcoming about the complexities and challenges associated with achieving transparency. This article will shed light on what businesses often don’t reveal about supply chain transparency, including its definition, why supply chains were not designed for transparency, the gaps in information collection, hidden benefits of transparency, and how TradeLink Technologies can play a pivotal role in advancing transparency.

1. Supply Chains Were Not Designed for Transparency

Historically, supply chains were not designed with transparency in mind. They evolved primarily to minimize costs, maximize efficiency, and respond to market demands quickly. Some of the key reasons for this lack of transparency include:

1. Complexity: Modern supply chains often involve multiple layers of suppliers and subcontractors, making it challenging to track and disclose every detail.

2. Cost Considerations: Transparency requires significant investment in technology, auditing, and reporting systems, which many companies may find prohibitively expensive.

3. Competitive Advantage: Companies may withhold information to maintain a competitive edge, fearing that disclosing too much could reveal proprietary processes or expose them to criticism.

The electronics industry, known for its complex supply chains, often struggles with transparency. Companies like Apple have faced criticism for not fully disclosing the working conditions in their supply chain, largely due to the intricate network of suppliers and concerns over competitive sensitivity.

2. Gaps in Upstream Supply Chain Information

One of the significant challenges in achieving supply chain transparency is the lack of information from upstream suppliers. Many businesses do not collect detailed data on their upstream supply chain for several reasons:

1. Data Collection Challenges: Gathering accurate data from suppliers, especially those in developing regions, can be difficult due to lack of infrastructure or technology.

2. Supplier Resistance: Some suppliers may be reluctant to share information due to fears of exposing substandard practices or facing increased scrutiny.

3. Regulatory Gaps: In many regions, regulations do not mandate detailed reporting, leading to a lack of comprehensive data collection.

In the fashion industry, although many brands are transparent about their direct suppliers, they often lack detailed information about labor conditions and environmental practices of their raw material suppliers, such as cotton farms or dye manufacturers. Acknowledging this, TradeLink focuses on developing RFID solutions that enhance data transparency, accuracy, and reliability. TradeLink’s RFID-based solutions for tracing raw materials have been and continue to help many leading garment factories in Vietnam address this challenge.

3.  Transparency Is About Being Honest And Disclosing

Supply chain transparency refers to the clear visibility and traceability of every step in the supply chain, from raw material sourcing to the final product reaching consumers. It involves providing detailed information about suppliers, manufacturing processes, and environmental and labor practices. 

Patagonia serves as an exemplary model of transparency that many companies aspire to follow. Founded in 1973 by Yvon Chouinard, Patagonia is an American outdoor clothing company known for its high-quality gear and strong commitment to sustainability. Through ethical sourcing, environmental activism, its Worn Wear Program for recycling and repairs garments, and using renewable energy, Patagonia has set a high standard for environmental stewardship. Their extensive transparency practices also make them a model for other companies. Here’s how they demonstrate this value:

• Public reporting: Patagonia’s Footprint Chronicles is an online portal where the company shares detailed information about the environmental and social impacts of its products. It includes case studies on various aspects of their supply chain, such as the sourcing of materials and factory conditions.
• Supply chain disclosure: Patagonia publishes a list of its suppliers on its website, detailing the factories that produce its goods. This openness allows consumers and stakeholders to understand the origins of the products they purchase.
• Certification and standards: Patagonia has integrated Fair Trade Certified™ practices into its supply chain, ensuring fair wages and safe working conditions for workers. Being a Certified B Corporation, Patagonia meets rigorous standards of social and environmental performance, accountability, and transparency.
• Annual reports: The company produces detailed annual reports that outline its progress towards sustainability goals, challenges encountered, and areas for improvement.

This extent of openness allows consumers to make informed choices and holds the company accountable for its practices, yielding significant benefits, such as enhanced brand loyalty, competitive edge, operational efficiency in the long run, and positive public image. 

4. Transparency: Beyond Just  Positive Public Image

While transparency in supply chains requires effort and investment, it offers several hidden benefits that can significantly enhance a business’s value:

1. Enhanced Consumer Trust: Transparency builds consumer confidence, as customers are increasingly drawn to brands that demonstrate ethical practices.

2. Risk Mitigation: By revealing and addressing potential risks in the supply chain, businesses can avoid costly scandals and disruptions.

3. Operational Efficiency: Transparency can lead to improved supply chain management and efficiency by identifying inefficiencies and areas for improvement.

4. Attracting Talent: Companies known for their ethical practices are often more attractive to employees who prioritize values and sustainability.

5. Conclusion

Supply chain transparency is more than a buzzword; it is a critical aspect of modern business practices that can lead to enhanced consumer trust, operational efficiency, and risk management. While businesses often do not fully disclose the complexities and challenges associated with achieving transparency, understanding these aspects is essential for making informed decisions. Embracing transparency not only aligns businesses with ethical practices but also paves the way for a more sustainable and responsible global economy.

References:

qimaone.4-important-benefits.open-graph.title. (n.d.). https://www.qimaone.com/resource-hub/benefits-of-supply-chain-transparency 

Bateman, A. (2021, January 20). What Supply Chain Transparency Really Means. Harvard Business Review. https://hbr.org/2019/08/what-supply-chain-transparency-really-means 

What Is Supply Chain Transparency? | IBM. (n.d.). https://www.ibm.com/topics/supply-chain-transparency#:~:text=Supply%20chain%20transparency%20allows%20businesses,that%20occur%20along%20the%20way 

Mje. (2023, November 22). Op-Ed: Patagonia Proves the Success of Sustainable Corporations – Michigan Journal of Economics. https://sites.lsa.umich.edu/mje/2023/11/22/op-ed-patagonia-proves-the-success-of-sustainable-corporations/ 

Mainwaring S. (2011, April 25). Patagonia: The Power of Brand Transparency. https://www.fastcompany.com/1749656/patagonia-power-brand-transparency 

China: Apple accused of violating labour laws as employees at iPhone factory found working 100 hours of overtime & being ‘punished’ for not meeting targets; Incl. co. comments – Business & Human Rights Resource Centre. (n.d.). Business & Human Rights Resource Centre. https://www.business-humanrights.org/en/latest-news/china-apple-accused-of-violating-labour-laws-as-employees-at-iphone-factory-found-working-100-hours-of-overtime-being-punished-for-not-meeting-targets-incl-co-comments/ 

Chan, E. (2022, July 14). We Still Don’t Have Enough Transparency In Fashion. British Vogue. https://www.vogue.co.uk/fashion/article/fashion-transparency-index-2022 

Cotton: Why transparency is so difficult and yet so important. (2022, December 5). Muntagnard. https://muntagnard.com/en/blogs/experience-munagnard/cotton-why-transparency-is-so-difficult-and-yet-so-important 

—

About TradeLink Technologies,

TradeLink Technologies (TradeLink) was founded in 1999 with a mission to create advanced supply chain solutions for global brands and retailers. We provide visibility, accuracy, and advanced distribution solutions for over 400 global brands and more than 50 logistics companies, leveraging a network of over 11,000 suppliers across 70 countries. With our latest local and cloud-based scanning and barcode applications, our solutions are scalable to fit businesses of all sizes. TradeLink’s strength lies in our industry expertise in supply chain management and utilization of cutting-edge technology. Learn more at: www.tradelinkone.com